Aap Jaisa Koi X Review: R Madhavan-Fatima's slow-burn romance wins hearts, movie gets mixed reactions

R Madhavan and Fatima Sana Shaikh’s film Aap Jaisa Koi is winning hearts for its tender romance and performances, though the screenplay has received mixed reactions from audiences on X. 

Image Credit : Social Media

R Madhavan returns to the romantic-comedy genre with Aap Jaisa Koi, and fans couldn’t be happier. The film, which recently premiered on Netflix, has generated a lot of buzz on social media, especially on X (formerly Twitter). Directed by Vivek Soni and produced by Karan Johar’s Dharmatic Entertainment, the film stars Madhavan as Madhu and Fatima Sana Shaikh as Shrirenu, two individuals exploring the possibility of love through a modern yet emotional lens.

Image Credit : instagram

Praise for Performances and Chemistry 

Audiences have largely praised the mature and heartfelt performances of Madhavan and Fatima. Their chemistry has been described as “quiet magic” and “deeply emotional,” with fans appreciating the film’s gentle tone and grown-up storytelling. One user wrote, “Aap Jaisa Koi is a tender, grown-up love story that lingers. Madhavan & Fatima bring quiet magic to a tale of loss, connection & second chances.” Another post said, “I needed this film to be good, and it delivers. Everything is great but Ayesha Raza wins this round.”

Madhavan’s portrayal of a middle-aged man navigating modern relationships has struck a chord with viewers, while Fatima’s performance has also been called top-notch. Many have also appreciated how the film speaks about important social themes, like patriarchy, without being preachy.

Aap jaisa koi is a MUST watch. I really needed this film to be good. And it delivers. Everything is great but Ayesha Raza wins this round. pic.twitter.com/u9qRpY9tye

— ThatsWhatSheSaid (@zeishahamlani) July 11, 2025

#AapJaisaKoi is easily the most stunningly shot Hindi film of 2025 so far. Shot by Debojeet Ray. Directed by Vivek Soni. pic.twitter.com/qo3jGnNymQ

— Aravind (@Reflections1212) July 12, 2025

Image Credit : Social Media

Mixed Screenplay Response but Strong Emotional Core 

While most users loved the romance and acting, the screenplay received mixed reactions. Some viewers felt that the pacing was too slow, but others believed it added to the film’s emotional depth. One fan tweeted, “Poetic, slow-burning, and emotionally rich,” capturing the film’s tone perfectly.

Despite the mixed screenplay reviews, Aap Jaisa Koi has managed to win hearts with its honesty, strong performances, and thoughtful storytelling. It's a film that aims to linger — and for many, it does just that.