Kolkata rape-murder horror: TMC's Mahua Moitra faces backlash over 'fake news' claims on victim's autopsy
By Sunita Iyer | First Published Aug 20, 2024, 1:27 PM ISTTMC leader Mahua Moitra is facing widespread criticism after her recent comments on social media regarding the autopsy of a junior doctor who was allegedly raped and murdered at Kolkata's RG Kar Medical College and Hospital.
TMC leader Mahua Moitra is facing widespread criticism after her recent comments on social media regarding the autopsy of a junior doctor who was allegedly raped and murdered at Kolkata's RG Kar Medical College and Hospital. The incident has sparked nationwide outrage and protests, leading to a massive backlash against Moitra for her remarks dismissing certain details about the victim's autopsy as "fake news."
Latest Videos
The controversy erupted after Moitra took to X (formerly Twitter) to address the ongoing public outrage, stating, "Genuine concerns about women’s safety in the workplace need citizens speaking out. But BJP playbook on misinformation & how to destabilise @MamataOfficial isn’t going to work. Poor patients are suffering - urging doctors to please resume duties."
Genuine concerns about women’s safety in the workplace need citizens speaking out. But BJP playbook on misinformation & how to destabilise isn’t going to work.
Poor patients are suffering - urging doctors to please resume duties.
In a series of posts, Moitra sought to clarify aspects of the autopsy report, stating that it showed "NO fracture to pelvic girdle or other bones," and that the "150 gm" referenced in the report pertained to the weight of the genitalia, not an "imaginary amount of fluid." She urged people not to spread "fake news."
"Writ filed in Kolkata HC by mischievous politician lawyers has WRONG info: 1. NO hurried cremation. Police escorted body home to Sodepur where family did cremation 2. NO broken bones. Autopsy does not mention fracture 3. NO “150gm semen”. That was weight of genitalia," the TMC leader added.
RG Kar autopsy in presence of judicial magistrate & 3 doctors:
1. Show NO fracture to pelvic girdle or other bones
2. 150 gm refer to weight of inner & outer genitalia NOT to imaginary amount of fluid
3. Does NOT suggest multiple assailants
Do NOT spread fake news please.
Writ filed in Kolkata HC by mischievous politician lawyers has WRONG info:
1. NO hurried cremation. Police escorted body home to Sodepur where family did cremation
2. NO broken bones. Autopsy does not mention fracture
3. NO “150gm semen”. That was weight of genitalia
However, her remarks have ignited a storm of criticism, with many accusing her of downplaying the severity of the crime and attempting to shield the West Bengal government from scrutiny. One irate user on X responded, "Finally Mahua Moitra speaks on #RGKarMedicalcollege rape case. She denies the brutality and threaten people for speaking on it... Slow claps!!!"
Another user added, "Nothing surprising. These TMC women were supporting Sandeshkhali criminal."
A third user remarked, "Did she even meet the parents? Were you at the march, or did you just feel like that was enough? Where's the principal? Did they call the family? Investigate the vandalism? How much more, madam?"
"After getting blocked from her for asking questions, don't expect anything good from her for the people of Bengal," said a fourth user on X.
Here's a look at some of the reactions to Mahua Moitra's first remarks on the Kolkata rape-murder horror:
Nothing surprising. These TMC women were supporting Sandeshkhali criminal.
— Aditya Vikram (@AdityaVikram096)Did she even meet the parents? Were you at the march, or did you just feel like that was enough? Where's the principal? Did they call the family? Investigate the vandalism? How much more, madam?
— 47Sha (@47Sha_)Now you know the reason why they pressurized the family member to cremate the body at the earliest. Wait for few days they will say "It was just a normal rape. Nothing to worry about."
Sick mentality of these morons. https://t.co/Ic9WGcJ5CE
Madam Mahua, listen to what SC is saying. Are they also fake news peddlers? https://t.co/Dm4tHwLnJj
— Nisarg Gandhi (@nisargvgandhi)For spreading fake news, a FIR needs to be registered against Mahua. Do we have any advocate to file? https://t.co/6qpQQZze3g
— Pankaj S Jain (@iampankajsjain)The only fake news we've heard yet -
Mamata Banerjee is the saviour of democracy and FoE! pic.twitter.com/hH9X5eeEfz
She doesn't seem to believe in condemning the act. She was just waiting for the reports to state the facts.
— Life11 (@schakrabarti1)She should clarify that why she blocked everyone who was raising voice.
— Adarsh Anand (@ExplorerAdarsh)She and her party have invested taxpayers money to hire Kapil Sibal. The guy says all in social media is wrong.
The case should be with CBI and investigated thoroughly. The way they are defending the management, there is more to it than meets the eye
Has she got access to postmoterm report?
And if yes with what authority?
Is she CM HM or HM?
Slow claps and tight slaps is what she needs..how can she deny such a gruesome and heinous act done with her fellow woman and try to defend the culprits..I don’t think she has any humanity left in her..all she wants is money !!
— Rajdeep Roy (@sneakylilbeech)Adding to the backlash, the Supreme Court on Tuesday came down heavily on the West Bengal government for its handling of the case. The apex court criticized the delay in filing an FIR and expressed concern over the safety of women in the workplace. The bench, headed by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud, emphasized the need for national protocols to ensure the safety of doctors, particularly female practitioners, and questioned how a mob of thousands was able to enter the hospital premises unchecked.
The court also scrutinized the actions of the RG Kar Medical College principal, who reportedly tried to pass off the crime as a suicide. The principal's immediate transfer to another institution despite ongoing investigations has raised further concerns about the conduct of the hospital authorities.
The doctors' strike over the incident, which has now entered its second week, continues to disrupt healthcare services, leaving many patients without necessary medical attention. The striking doctors have demanded that the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), which was ordered to take over the case by the Calcutta High Court, apprehend the culprits and ensure the harshest punishment. They are also seeking assurances from the government that measures will be put in place to prevent such tragedies in the future.
The victim, a junior doctor, was found dead with severe injuries inside the seminar hall of the hospital's chest department on August 9. A civic volunteer was arrested in connection with the case the following day. The ongoing investigation by the CBI, which began on August 14, follows a high court order in response to petitions filed by the victim's parents and other concerned parties.
subscribe to Asianet Newsable WhatsApp channel by clicking here. For more reliable and latest news
subscribe to Asianet Newsable Telegram channel by clicking here.