28 years later, verdict in Sister Abhaya case today
More than 28 years after Sister Abhaya was mysteriously found dead, the CBI Special Court in Thiruvananthapuram will pronounce its verdict in the case today. The Sister Abhaya case has over the years witnessed several unexpected twists.
FollowOver 28 years since Sister Abhaya was mysteriously found dead, the CBI Special Court in Thiruvananthapuram will pronounce its verdict in the case today.
Sister Abhaya was found dead in the well of Pious Xth Convent in Kottayam on March 27, 1992.
The Sister Abhaya case, which has over the years seen several twists, had been written off as suicide by the Kerala police and then by the crime branch. The CBI, which took over the investigation a year later, had filed three reports in the high court seeking to end the case citing lack of evidence. However, the high court rejected the reports and ordered a new investigation.
The new investigation team made the first arrests in the case on November 19, 2008. Father Thomas M Kottur is the first accused, Father Jose Poothrikkayil was second accused and Sister Sefi was the third accused. Father Jose Poothrikkayil was acquitted by the trial court citing lack of evidence.
The trial in the CBI special court started only on August 26, 2019.
According to reports, the CBI team had concluded that sister Abhaya was murdered by priests Thomas Kottoor, Jose Puthrukayil and Sister Sefi. The agency claimed that the 18-year-old nun happened to witness the accused in a compromising position and was killed fearing that she might spill the beans.
During the trial, nine witnesses, including Sister Abhaya’s roommate Sister Sherly, turned hostile.
A crucial testimony in the case was that of forensic expert Dr V Kandaswamy who told the CBI special court in Thiruvananthapuram that she died because of the injury inflicted on head and that it was not a case of suicide.
Observing that Sister Abhaya's death did not have signs of suicide, Dr V Kandaswamy said six injuries on the nun's head -- especially the deep wound in the middle part -- was the cause of her death.
B Raman Pillai, counsel for Father Thomas Kottoor, had argued that that the prosecution had cooked up a tale and that his client had turned into an accused as per that story only. He argued that the statements of the witnesses against Kottoor were unreliable, doubtful and hence could not be accepted as evidence.
The trial ended on December 11 after which the judge posted the verdict for December 22.
